Color or Colorless

While I pretty much only take photographs in color, I frequently convert them to black and white.  This is a stylistic/artistic decision.   As a matter of fact, generally, unless color is a key part of the photo, I will make them colorless.  Black and white pictures just seem a bit further removed from reality to me, and more satisfying artistically. 

Here's one photograph where I had problems deciding.  I liked this shot for a few reasons.  Iwas struck by how alike these girls seemed, in particular their sunglasses.  Also, the bored looks as they seemingly are waiting for something or someone (they are seated outside of the Millenium Hotel across from the World Trade Center site).  An online friend pointed out the reflection of their legs against the wall behind is interesting.  And, the girl on the left is looking off, almost like she has been startled by something off camera. 

Sunglasses and Pouts (color)

Argument for color:  This shot was taken at dusk, so the the light had an orange tinge to it.  The trees created a somewhat natural vignetting effect.  The purple dress and red scarf kind of pop and helps center your attention on them.  Also, the purple dress ties together with the purple flowers on the left side.  It works well in color but there is not a lot of color here. 

Sunglasses and Pouts (black and white)

Argument for black and white:   This version is much more contrasty.  The girls look more comic-bookish and are less realistic.  Their sunglasses are even more prominently noticed.  I like this version as well, maybe better.

You be the judge, look below as the picture converts back and forth.